Back to Remains/Vietnam

rose.jpg (4818 bytes)

AMERICANS IDENTIFIED SINCE 1989
WWII, KOREA, COLD WAR

Jan 2005 - Dec 2005
Jan 2006 - May 2007
June 2007 - Dec 2008

2009

red.gif (1122 bytes)

rose.jpg (4818 bytes)

Tears, joy, relief as family welcomes home SB airman who died 65 years ago
http://www.sbsun.com/news/ci_13663654

ONTARIO - Sgt. Robert Stinson came home Wednesday to a hero's welcome after more than 60 years in a watery wartime grave.

His brothers, Dick and Edward Stinson, briefly touched his flag-draped casket as it moved down the ramp and out of a United Airlines Airbus at Ontario International Airport.

"I never thought I'd see this day," said Edward Stinson, younger brother of the airman missing since his B-24 Liberator bomber was shot down by Japanese fighters in the South Pacific on Sept. 1, 1944.

Dick and Edward are all that's left of six brothers who grew up in San Bernardino, played ball together and "joked around a lot." Tall men who towed the line when their 5-foot 2-inch mother scolded them.

 

Military honor guards carry the remains of World War II Sgt. Robert Stinson, missing in action nearly 65 years after the plane he was aboard crashed in the South Pacific, to a waiting hearse at L.A./Ontario International Airport on Wednesday. Stinson's remains were found five years ago and identified using DNA. A memorial service will be held for him today at Bobbitt Memorial Chapel in San Bernardino. (Will Lester / Staff Photographer)
About a dozen other members of the Stinson family joined them on the tarmac as the remains of their lost World War II hero arrived from Hawaii.

Ted Stinson of Kingman, Ariz., Dick's son, said his dad has not been in an airplane since his brother went missing in the war.

"My dad's as happy as I've seen him in a long time. He has had so much sadness all these years," the younger Stinson said, his eyes watering.

"We're blessed as a family to know what took place and we want to honor him in a way he should be honored."

More than 30 Patriot Guard Riders lined the fence and saluted, flags waving, as a color guard carried the Stinson casket to a waiting hearse.

Stinson was only 23 years old when he was killed.

Vintage photos show him youthful and handsome, 6-feet 4-inches tall with an easy smile.

Edward was 9 when his brother died.

"Bob was my No. 1 hero," he said, "my brother Dick, over there, is my second," Edward Stinson said.

When Bob was missing in action, the brothers thought about him every night, they said.

"We didn't know where he was, didn't know anyone was looking for him," Edward said, choking back a sob.

Posthumously, Robert Stinson was awarded the Purple Heart, an Air Medal and Oak-Leaf Cluster, as well as a variety of other honors for his service to his country.

"I break up thinking about it - it's not sorrow, it's happiness. I never dreamed of having a day like this," the 74-year-old Edward Stinson said.

He and his wife, Alice, were among the welcoming family members that also included their son, Dave Stinson, of Highland.

"It's a happy day - it's a miracle," said Dick Stinson, 87, who served as a B-24 gunner during World War II, flying 91 missions in the Pacific.

For 60 years, Sgt. Stinson and seven fellow crew members of the bomber, "Babes in Arms," lay in 70 feet of water off the Western Pacific island of Palau.

In 2004, volunteer divers with the BentProp organization found the wreckage, broken into three sections on a coral reef.

Under the auspices of the Joint POW-MIA Accounting Command, the site was searched and Stinson's remains found.

Stinson was identified by DNA samples from Edward Stinson and brother Dick, of Yuba City, in 2006.

The remains and artifacts from the wreckage were brought up during four dives between 2004 and 2008.

Boots, parts of uniforms, watches, a shoelace in perfect condition, according to Edward Stinson.

The fallen airman was escorted to Bobbitt Memorial Chapel, where a public service is scheduled from 5 to 7 p.m. today at 1299 E. Highland Ave., San Bernardino.

Burial is set for 11 a.m. Friday at Riverside National Cemetery, 22495 Van Buren Blvd.

michel.nolan@inlandnewspapers.com
(909) 386-3859

=================================

Veteran missing for 58 years to be buried

The Oak Ridger
Posted Oct 19, 2009 @ 09:00 AM

OAK RIDGE, Tenn. —

An Oak Ridge woman whose veteran brother was missing in Korea for 58 years, and presumed dead, will see him buried at home this week.

The remains of U.S. Army Sgt. Lawrence Alexander Meredith were identified earlier this year, and he will be laid to rest in a military funeral on Thursday afternoon in Lewisburg, W. Va., his older sister Lucy Wolfenbarger said.

Meredith will be buried in the same cemetery as his parents in the family's mountainous hometown, said Wolfenbarger, one of the veteran's eight siblings and a long-time Oak Ridge resident.

Meredith, a former farm boy and football player, was declared missing in action Feb. 13, 1951, during intense fighting near a town called Wonju. That was after U.S. forces had retreated from a battle with the Chinese Army about 50 miles east of Seoul, South Korea, according to Wolfenbarger and U.S. Army records.

"The Chinese captured him," Wolfenbarger said.

Twenty years old and a corporal when he was taken prisoner, Meredith was later presumed dead, and a memorial was held for him in 1953.

"We just figured we'd never see him again," Wolfenbarger said.

But earlier this summer, Army personnel told Wolfenbarger, 85, that they had identified her youngest brother's remains, which had been turned over by North Korea in 1993.

"They called me June 2 ... and told me they found my brother," Wolfenbarger said. "I just figured it might be a prank call."

But, no, the caller insisted, this was real.

In 1993, the Democratic People's Republic of (North) Korea had turned over 34 boxes, or "coffins," believed to contain the remains of U.S. servicemen listed as missing from the Korean War. More than a decade later, a laboratory at the Joint POW/MIA Accounting Command at Hickam Air Force Base in Hawaii concluded that some of them belonged to Meredith.

Wolfenbarger and her youngest sister -- the only two surviving children of the nine siblings -- submitted to a DNA test in 2007 to help identify their brother's remains, apparently recovered from a site near a North Korean prisoner of war facility.

Wolfenbarger said she does not know how or when her brother's life ended.

She had not known that he had been a prisoner of war, or POW, until U.S. Army personnel visited her last month and gave her a notebook filled with information on her long-missing sibling, including a skeletal photograph and a memo establishing his identity.

Wolfenbarger said she feels more peaceful now that her brother has been identified, but the news hasn't completely registered yet.

"It might after I get to the funeral," she said.

John Huotari can be contacted at (865) 220-5533.

===========================================

Epilogue for a lost Marine

By Kevin Cullen
Globe Columnist / October 22, 2009

Billy Lynch left Dorchester 72 years ago, and they’re pretty sure they’ve finally found him, a long way from home, deep in the ground in China.

Staff Sergeant Billy Lynch was a Marine. He grew up on Victory Road, and if you go to the corner of Victory and Neponset Avenue, you’ll see the black street sign with the gold star that commemorates William Joseph Lynch Square. It is a place of honor for a Marine who disappeared 67 years ago.

He left Neponset for the Marines in 1937, right out of high school, and never came back. He was stationed in China when the Japanese bombed Pearl Harbor, and then went to the Philippines and was there when the Japanese invaded. After the battle of Corregidor in 1942, the Japanese took him prisoner.

They beat him but couldn’t break him. As soon as he could run, Billy Lynch ran from the prison camp. The Japanese caught him and beat him again, worse, and then they put him on a “hell ship’’ to China, with no ventilation, no toilet, no water, no food. It was a death march at sea.

A lot of POWs died on the hell ships, but Billy Lynch wouldn’t give his captors the satisfaction. They stuck him in a prison camp called Mukden and he escaped again. Some of the local Chinese hid him, but a 6-foot white guy from Dorchester stood out in Manchuria, and the Japanese recaptured him.

They beat him again, and there would be no third escape for Billy Lynch. He was sent to another camp, Port Arthur, now known by its Chinese name, Lushun. Billy Lynch’s captors tortured him, peeling the skin from his body before killing him, cutting him up, and stuffing his remains in a barrel that was sealed.

Some years ago, a Chinese historian named Yang Jing became intrigued with Prisoner No. 610, the only American POW never accounted for in China. He started digging, figuratively, looking for Billy Lynch.

Professor Yang found three elderly Chinese men who were slave laborers at Port Arthur and knew about the murder, dismemberment, and burial of Staff Sergeant Billy Lynch.

When Yang learned that Lynch was from Boston, he contacted John McColgan, the city’s archivist. McColgan knocked on every door on Victory Road but couldn’t find anyone who remembered the Lynches. McColgan asked Marie Daly, a genealogist at the New England Historic Genealogical Society, for help.

Daly, a detective in librarian’s clothing, found Lynch’s two nieces, Judy Armour in Bridgewater and Janet Sambuceti in Marshfield. Their DNA will prove, once and for all, whether Billy Lynch is in the ground in Manchuria.

Yesterday, a FedEx pilot named Ryan Bach and a former Marine from Norwell named Mark Voner walked around the spot in Lushun where they believe Billy Lynch’s bones rest. It’s getting too cold to dig, so the plan is to bring in an archeological team next spring.

Bach and Voner are part of a volunteer group called Moore’s Marauders, dedicated to finding American MIAs like Billy Lynch. Moore’s Marauders will send scientists over next spring.

Voner was badly wounded when the Marine barracks in Beirut was blown up in 1983, killing 241 Marines, soldiers, and sailors.

“It’s fitting that there is a Marine there right now, looking for the last Marine in China,’’ said Fred Sullivan, one of the Dorchester residents who support the cause of finding Billy Lynch. “We had to raise $25,000 to pay for the search, but it’s worth every penny. Billy Lynch should come home.’’

If, as they believe, their dig next spring yields Billy Lynch’s bones, he will come home, finally, first to St. Ann’s Church, where he made his First Communion, then on to Arlington National Cemetery.

“He deserves to be home,’’ Judy Armour said of the uncle she never met and never forgot. “That’s why he kept escaping. He kept trying, no matter what they did to him. He wanted to come home.’’

Kevin Cullen is a Globe columnist. He can be reached at cullen@globe.com.

=========================================

http://www.twincities.com/allheadlines/ci_13236490

A Marine on St. Croix man finally learns the fate of his MIA brother

A Marine on St. Croix man finally learns the airman's World War II plane crashed — and that villagers buried Kenneth Seidel's body.

It's been more than 60 years since Loren Seidel's brother disappeared somewhere over the Himalayas.

He always wondered what happened, imagining his brother — a World War II airman — had been captured as a prisoner of war.

But earlier this year, Loren got the call he'd stopped hoping for long ago.

"We never thought we'd hear anything like this, that they discovered his airplane," Loren, 83, said last week at his Marine on St. Croix home.

An American mountaineer had discovered the crash site of a World War II cargo plane in remote north-east India. Among its four-member crew had been its flight engineer, Pfc. Kenneth L. Seidel, of St. Paul.

Loren said it feels good to finally get some news about his big brother.

He and his sister, Dorothy Buhl, 81, of Oakdale, hope Kenneth's remains might be recovered and one day make it home for a proper burial, though military officials haven't promised anything.

On Saturday, Loren and his wife, Ellen, 84, attended an update by the Department of Defense in the Twin Cities for families of MIA/POW soldiers.

They learned a lot, Ellen said. Though military representatives spoke of possible upcoming recovery missions, they didn't specifically name Kenneth's site. Many planes went down there, and each crash site is quite large, Ellen said.

"(Loren) says that — and I think we both feel — it's a big question of whether they'd (Kenneth's remains) come back or not," Ellen said after the meeting.

"To me it would be a big surprise if there was something, but it would be nice. For Loren's sake and for Dorothy's sake, it would be nice if they found something."

The Seidels haven't given up hope of interring Kenneth's remains beneath the stone already bearing his name, next to his mother at Oakland Cemetery in St. Paul. But they recognize that it could be years before that happens.

Loren was just 17 when Kenneth's plane disappeared in the China-Burma-India theatre (Burma is now known as Myanmar). Loren was in boot camp for the Marine Corps, and went on to serve in the war.

'ALUMINUM ALLEY'

Records show the plane, a C-46A with serial number 41-24739, took off from Kunming, China on Jan. 29, 1944, but never showed up at its destination in India.

The family never received personal effects or word of how Kenneth's plane might have gone down. Just a telegram declaring him missing shortly after his disappearance.

He was officially declared dead on April 10, 1945 — what would have been his 25th birthday.

The plane was flying "the Hump," as it was known, a common and dangerous route over the Himalaya Mountains for transporting supplies to China during the war. The area was so notorious for claiming planes it was dubbed Aluminum Alley.

Mountaineer Clayton Kuhles discovered the crash site in October of last year.

Kuhles, 55, a businessman from Prescott, Ariz., began exploring the China-Burma-India theater region in 2000, and has logged 15 similar crash-site discoveries — all American planes from the second world war.

"I found out that no one had ever gone looking for these men," said Kuhles, reached at home last week. "I decided to make it a personal crusade of mine. I've just taken on the project, and it's become a real passion of mine."

To track down the family members of missing soldiers, Kuhles enlisted the help of Gary Zaetz, whose uncle was lost in the war. Zaetz was like the Seidels — more curious than hopeful — when he came across Kuhles' Web site, miarecoveries.org.

"I was just stunned," said Zaetz, 54, of Cary, N.C. "I didn't expect to find any information like this at all. I was just hoping to find something on my uncle's war record, and there was Clayton's Web site saying he had found my uncle's plane."

It was Zaetz who called the Seidels in February about Kuhles' discovery.

RELIEF HE WASN'T TAKEN PRISONER

For them, the news was bittersweet.

"I got a call. He said, 'I'm calling about Kenneth Seidel,' " Ellen recalled. "I said, 'I just buried him.' "

The Seidels had named their first son after Loren's brother. The younger Kenneth was a Vietnam veteran and died just a week before they were contacted about the discovery.

"I wish he had lived to ..." Ellen said, tearing up.

At first, Loren and Ellen thought the call was a hoax. They thought someone had seen the obituary and was preying on them. Family members cautioned that the caller probably was just looking for money.

But an Internet-savvy granddaughter guided the Seidels through Kuhles' Web site, which contained photos of the crash site, names of crewmembers and similar details for the other missing World War II planes he's discovered.

"Then I did feel it was real," Loren said.

According to Kuhles' written report, the plane crashed in a jungle-covered area near the Indian village of Rilu, in the state of Arunachal Pradesh. It was seen approaching from the north, struck the crest of the hill and slid into a ravine.

Kuhles met a local woman who witnessed the crash. She said the plane was on fire when it slid down the mountainside. She and other Indian villagers buried the crewmembers on site, Loren said.

The news was a relief, at long last.

"Loren always wondered," Ellen said. "(When he learned) they were buried on site, it gave him peace of mind that he wasn't captured (by the enemy). It gives us peace of mind that that didn't happen."

74,000 STILL MISSING

Kuhles funds each of his trips independently, with help from donations from thankful families here and there. Although he reports each of his discoveries to the Joint POW/MIA Accounting Command — an arm of the Department of Defense whose responsibility is recovering military remains — Kuhles gets no help or funding from the federal government.

JPAC officials say they're aware of the work Kuhles has done and are working on making recoveries in that region. They were negotiating with the Indian government when Kuhles announced his discoveries, said JPAC spokesman Lt. Col. Wayne Perry.

The group is planning a recovery mission in that area this fall, Perry said.

"We generally do about 100 or so missions a year, spread across all three conflicts (World War II and Vietnam and Korean wars)," Perry said. "We're pretty successful, but it doesn't always mean we bring something home. And just because we bring remains home this year, doesn't mean we can ID them this year."

The mountains in the CBI theater reach more than 25,000 feet in some spots. The C-46A topped out at 24,500 feet. The low-flying cargo planes often had to weave through mountaintops in treacherous weather conditions.

It's believed that several hundred planes were lost in Aluminum Alley and more than 1,300 crewmen are unaccounted for, Perry said. The number of American World War II personnel still missing is 74,384, he said.

Kuhles and Zaetz are committed to helping as many families as possible find closure for the soldiers and pilots who went missing in that region.

"I expect to continue helping (Kuhles) locate relatives for as long as I live," Zaetz said. "It's just that important that we remember the sacrifice that these airmen made."

Elizabeth Mohr can be reached at 651-228-5162.

================================

 
WW II pilot's remains coming home to Akron

Posted by Brian Albrecht/Plain Dealer Reporter August 22, 2009 19:19PM

VIDEO: Relatives of B-24 co-pilot Alden Hershiser talk about the discovery and burial of the Akron native's remains 64 years after he went missing in action.

1st Lt. Alden Hershiser

 

April 4, 1945. It's his 35th and last required mission as World War II in Europe winds into its final month. Just drop the bombs, then head back home to Akron.

He's the 24-year-old co-pilot of a B-24 Liberator bomber nicknamed "Trouble N Mind," flying 10,000 feet over Havelberg, Germany.

Suddenly there's the flash of a German fighter -- a jet, Messerschmitt 262, Hitler's last secret weapon. Too few, too late to change the outcome of the war, but still deadly.

The bomber's cockpit fills with smoke and fire. Bail out! He jumps, his parachute flaming. Falling fast. Too fast. Hits the ground hard. Fatally.

Someone finds his body. Knocks out his gold fillings. Buries him in a shallow grave. Years pass. Decades. Gone -- missing in action -- but not entirely lost.

Now, 64 years later, 1st Lt. Alden Hershiser is finally making that long-delayed trip home.

Hershiser's remains were dug out of the forest two years ago but were positively identified only last month. He will be brought back to his hometown for burial on Sept. 11, Patriot Day, in Rose Hill Cemetery beside his father and mother -- who went to her death in 1978 never giving up hope that somehow her son was still alive.

The discovery of his remains came as a surprise to his brother, Bill Hershiser, and niece, Susan Adair, both of Kent.

"It was just like a big WOW!" said Hershiser. "I can't believe this."

Adair said that because the airman was seen parachuting from the stricken B-24, her grandmother "always believed he was still alive, and a POW, and had amnesia. That was kind of the story we had been told for many, many years."

So when contacted by the Joint Prisoners of War, Missing in Action Accounting Command, or JPAC, last year regarding her long-lost relative, she said, "I was shocked. We were all just shocked."

Hershiser is one of 180 Americans missing in action during World War II whom JPAC has identified since 2003. An estimated 74,384 are still unaccounted for from the war.

Chris McDermott, historian with the government agency based in Hawaii, said the JPAC staff's interest in the case started in 1998 when the family of the "Trouble N Mind" bombardier (one of the three crewmen killed) went to Havelberg and placed an ad in a local newspaper, seeking information about the crash.

 

1st Lt. Alden Hershiser of Akron poses beside some shapely artwork on a B-24 bomber while serving with the 448th Bomber Group in England during World War II.


More stories about those who served in World War II

It wasn't until 2007 that local historical interest resulted in exhumation of an American airman's grave that foresters had kept secret.

 

The remains were flown to Hawaii, and subsequent interviews in 2008 with people in Germany determined that the "Trouble N Mind" provided the best candidates for possible identification through comparison to the three crewmen's medical service records. The Army's Casualty Office was asked to locate surviving families.

About the same time, Susan Adair attended a high school reunion, met former classmate John Beckwith of Kent and discovered that he was searching for information about a relative lost during World War II.

She asked if he could find out anything about her father's brother, and Beckwith spent a year locating Hershiser's flight records, old photos and even surviving crewmen.

Adair believes JPAC was able to find and contact her family because of Beckwith's search efforts over the Internet.

Beckwith said, "Coincidence, luck, circumstance, being in the right place at the right time, is basically what happened."

When authorities called Bill Hershiser, seeking a DNA sample for comparison to the remains, he was initially reluctant.

He was only 5 years old when his brother was killed, never really knew him and spent a lifetime without thinking much about him. "Then all at once, Boom! He pops back into your life," Hershiser said.

The DNA test would bring back either a brother, or disappointment.

Though his brother was gone, the impact of the loss had always lingered. Their mother had urged her last surviving child never to enlist in the service, and he didn't.

Bill Hershiser's wife, Sally, said the boys' mother and Alden had been very close.

"She was very young when he was born, and they kind of grew up together," she said. "She would wait up for him after his dates, and they'd each have a cigarette and he would tell her about his dates."

Bill Fensch still has fond memories of cousin Alden, a graduate of Akron North High School. "We were good friends. We played baseball and used to go to the bakery to get day-old rolls and stuff," recalled Fensch, 88, of Clearwater, Fla.

Fensch said he served with the Army field artillery during the war and had been in Czechoslovakia when he got a letter from his mother, telling him of his cousin's disappearance over what would become the Soviet-controlled sector of Germany.

"They said his parachute opened and I'd worried ever since that the Russians got hold of him," Fensch said. "I'm happy they found his remains, so at least now I know he hadn't been captured and suffering all those years."

Susan Adair recalled that she once got a call from a woman who said she'd always had a crush on Alden Hershiser and just wanted to talk about him. "This is what, 1990. That's a long time to carry a torch," she said.

Through Beckwith, Adair got a copy of a journal written during the war by one of Hershiser's fellow crewmen. In it, the airman told of a time when his co-pilot got a little "flak happy" on one mission after having dreamed about the horrors of anti-aircraft fire the night before.

To Adair, the journal -- with its glimpses of the personal lives and fears of these bygone combatants -- adds a human element to the long-lost airman.

"It makes him real," she said. "It's comforting to me. You can tell they were living as much of a good life as they could."

The family also has another grim bit of reality -- a button from Hershiser's grave, sent to them along with JPAC's full report of the recovery and identification process.

The burial service for Alden Hershiser will include full military honors, including a possible fly-over salute, said Capt. Joseph Baibak, an Army casualty assistance officer who serves with the Ohio National Guard.

Baibak said he will accompany Hershiser's remains from airport to grave.

"He will not be left alone," Baibak said. "He's been alone long enough."

==============================================

Carlson: Lost over Hungary in 1945, Iowan is at last coming home

By JOHN CARLSON
jcarlson@dmreg.com

The 87-year-old woman asked me to repeat what I'd said to her in the Thursday afternoon phone call.

I said it again, and she gasped, shouted an "Oh, my God," and asked me to say it one more time, so she could be sure.

"Your husband - Marvin Steinford - he's coming home," I told her.

The Vinton woman took a couple of seconds to cry and said she