Media Coverage JULY 2009
|
In plain view
Military imposter's local presence irks
former allies
by Anthony
Lane
His grim-faced mug shot appeared in newspapers across the
country next to words like "imposter,"
"fraud" and "fake." A chorus of military
veterans and bloggers opined that his bogus tale about getting
his brain rattled while serving in Iraq should win him prison
time, if not a plane ride to the front lines and a chance to
finally "walk the walk."
All of which makes it strange to see Rick Strandlof, once a
prominent veterans' advocate known as Rick Duncan, calmly
surfing the Internet at a downtown Colorado Springs Starbucks.
So I ask the obvious question: "What are you
doing here?"
"Where else would I be?" the 32-year-old answers
blithely.
I don't mention that Mexico first comes to mind, and then
Louisiana. Or that in both scenarios, I imagine him with a fake
beard.
Whatever you think of Strandlof and the months he masqueraded
as a brain-injured veteran, the simple truth two months after
his web of lies came apart is that public disgrace seems to have
changed him little. As Duncan, he claimed to be a former Marine
Corps captain who, after barely surviving Iraq, was inspired to
help other veterans.
Now, Strandlof says he's a "mentally ill
individual" who got carried away. He sees helping veterans
as his "calling" but regrets that "bad
things" he said — like the whopper that he was inside the
Pentagon on Sept. 11 — hurt people.
"I'm gradually making apologies," says Strandlof,
who claims he's now taking medications for bipolar disorder,
depression and schizoaffective disorder, a mild form of
schizophrenia.
One person not waiting for an apology is Hal Bidlack, the
retired Air Force lieutenant colonel who frequently had
Strandlof at his side last year as he campaigned against U.S.
Rep. Doug Lamborn.
"I think all I would say to that guy is, 'I have nothing
to say to you,'" Bidlack says.
He expresses concern that Strandlof's ruse could be used
against him or other Democrats, and he sounds surprised — if
not mildly annoyed — that Strandlof has returned to places
like Poor Richard's, a popular downtown hangout for
progressives.
"I don't understand why he wouldn't go where he's
unknown," Bidlack says.
Despite the attention and resentment his case attracted,
Strandlof claims people "don't walk by and point." And
he's not worried the FBI is about to arrest him, either for
claiming false military heroics or embezzling donations to the
Colorado Veterans Alliance, the now-defunct nonprofit he was
trying to build.
"I haven't heard word in weeks," Strandlof says.
(Special Agent Kathy Wright, an FBI spokeswoman in Denver, says
the investigation is "ongoing.")
After being outed as a fraud in May, Strandlof spent three
weeks in jail on a misdemeanor traffic charge, apparently unable
to post bail. Now, somehow, he seems quite comfortable, using a
new-looking computer and sipping a coffee drink. Strandlof
refuses to say where he's getting money, but reiterates his
claim that he never kept donations for himself.
Dan Warvi, who found holes in Strandlof's story while working
on the Colorado Veterans Alliance, marvels that Strandlof,
always destitute in the past, now seems to have at least
moderate means as he hangs around in plain sight.
He sounds a note of caution in an e-mail: "I wouldn't
believe anything he says on anything."
— lane@csindy.com
|
http://www.navytimes.com/news/2009/07/navy_silver_stars_072609w/
Navy yet to name nearly 50 recipients
By Andrew
Scutro - Staff writer
Posted : Monday Jul 27, 2009 7:35:59 EDT
The Navy has awarded 63 Silver Stars to sailors and officers since
Sept. 11, 2001, a Navy spokesman said. The number is much higher than
previously thought.
Doug Sterner, an expert in combat award citations and curator of the
Military Times’ Hall of Valor project, has confirmed only 15 Navy
Silver Star recipients for the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan. The Silver
Star is the third-highest award for combat valor.
Of the 63 Silver Stars, 33 were awarded for action in Operation
Enduring Freedom — likely for action in Afghanistan — and 30 for
action in Iraq. The total does not include Marines who’ve been awarded
the medal.
Yet through official Navy channels, their identities and the
circumstances of their awards largely remain unknown.
A standing request by Navy Times dating to November for the names of
recipients remains stuck in the Pentagon. “We’re working to
determine which classifications can be publicly released,” Navy
spokesman Cmdr. Cappy Surette said Friday.
Sterner said some awardees earned the Silver Star for action on
classified missions, and their names are redacted on released citations.
Still, others have been publicly acknowledged at award ceremonies —
such as an explosive ordnance disposal technician for action in
Afghanistan — but the high number of 63 came as a surprise to those
who keep track.
Sterner said he believes there are many others whose identities are
unknown because of the sensitivity of action behind the award.
“I’ve heard reports there were as many as 23 SEALs remaining
unidentified as of last year,” Sterner said.
The most likely Navy recipients of the Silver Star in the current
wars are hospital corpsmen serving with Marine units, SEALs and EOD
techs.
By Sterner’s count, the 15 who have been identified are nine SEALs,
one EOD tech and five corpsmen.
Honor Roll
Silver Stars awarded to sailors and Navy officers from the late 1960s
through Sept. 11, 2001, not including the Vietnam War:
• Kosovo, 1999: 1.
• Somalia, 1993: 5.
• Operation Desert Storm, 1991: 0.
• Panama, 1989: 0 (2 Navy Crosses).
• Grenada, 1983: 1.
• Container ship Mayaguez incident, 1975: 2.
• Intelligence ship Pueblo incident, 1968: 2.
• Intelligence ship Liberty incident, 1967: 11.
|
Crowley vet's POW claims
raised red flag
Posted: 07/26/2009 01:00:00 AM MDT
A Vietnam veteran responsible for assisting other vets with their
benefits in Crowley County has been stripped of his state VFW office
and is under investigation for allegedly falsely claiming he had been
a prisoner of war.
Ronald Crumley, who denies lying about his record, is employed as
the county's veterans service officer. He has been receiving 100
percent disability payments based on the three years he says he was
held as a prisoner of war.
Crumley was a Marine. And he did earn a Purple Heart. But the POW
claims he made in May at a week-long Veterans Service Officer
conference "raised red flags," said Joe Potter, a veteran
and a member of Gov. Bill Ritter's Colorado Board of Veterans Affairs.
Potter said Crumley talked to a table of veterans every day at
lunch, describing how he was taken prisoner after nearly everyone else
in his company was killed.
Potter also said Crumley told the group he receives full disability
payments because of the trauma of his POW experience and claimed he
served for 30 years and flew 500 combat missions.
Crumley's service record shows he served 16 years and was a
mechanic.
Site calls him phony
Potter said he began researching Crumley's claims with real POWs.
He also turned to Doug Sterner, a Colorado Springs veteran and
military historian who has made a full-time job of exposing phony war
heroes, and to Mary Schantag, founder of the Missouri-based POW
Network.
They all reached the same finding: Crumley was never a POW and
other claims he had made about his service record are false.
Schantag has posted him under "phonies and wannabees" on
the POW Network website, and a Department of Veterans Affairs
investigator is now looking into his record.
"They are blowing this whole thing out of proportion,"
Crumley said when reached Wednesday.
Crumley said he was leaving for a funeral that day and couldn't
talk further. He promised that a former Marine general and a former
U.S. attorney general from Washington, D.C., will fly to Colorado this
week to support his claims.
"This is all because I stepped on some toes and got crosswise
with some high-ranking officials," he said.
Still a county employee
Mike McGrath, a former Vietnam POW from Monument, confirmed Friday
that Crumley's name is not among the 661 surviving Vietnam War POWs.
The Crowley County commissioners said he will continue to work as
their service officer.
"At this point, unless there is a charge proven, he is still
employed as our county officer," said Commissioner Matthew
Heimerich, noting that the controversy seemed to be based on
third-party reports and hearsay.
Colorado State VFW Commander Bill Esch confirmed that Crumley was
removed from his position as Colorado Junior Vice Commander and cannot
hold office in the organization for the next five years because he
used a VFW credit card to buy a laptop computer in 2007 in violation
of VFW rules.
"We took care of our issue with him and thought it was best to
remove him as a state officer," Esch said.
A felony violation
Sterner said he has notified the FBI about Crumley's claims because
falsely asserting POW status is a felony violation under the Stolen
Valor Act. Sterner said he believes Crumley has been receiving
benefits to which he is not entitled.
Questions about Crumley's record first surfaced after Colorado
Springs veterans activist Richard Strandlof was exposed as a fraud in
June. Strandlof, a.k.a. Rick Duncan, raised money for veterans causes
and spoke at veterans rallies, but never served in the military. He is
facing charges under the Stolen Valor Act.
Schantag pointed out that Crumley's false claims should be taken
seriously because he works in a position of trust.
"If he is lying about his record, what else is he lying
about?" she said.
Nancy Lofholm: 970-256-1957 or nlofholm@denverpost.com
|
Veteran’s POW, service claims
challenged
A Crowley County official
contends he can prove he was a POW.
By ANTHONY A. MESTAS
THE PUEBLO CHIEFTAIN
ORDWAY - The Crowley County veterans affairs officer is disputing
claims by military historians that he lied about being a prisoner of
war.
In a telephone interview Wednesday, Ronald Crumley said he is a former
POW and that he will prove it at a meeting next week.
"All of the allegations will be answered by two people. One is a
four-star Marine general and the other is a former assistant U.S.
attorney general," Crumley said.
"I see how this has happened to other people and I want to take
care of it now," Crumley said.
Crumley did not specify when or where the meeting will be held.
"There are some extenuating circumstances about what went on
(during his time in Vietnam) and they can answer those questions for you
next week," Crumley said.
He would not comment further.
The federal Stolen Valor Act includes penalties for those who falsely
assert they were POWs.
Military historian Doug Sterner of Pueblo and Mary Schantag, a
researcher for the POW Network, said that Crumley never was a prisoner
of war.
Crumley is listed on POWnetwork.org
under its "phonies and wannabes" section as claiming to be a
Vietnam prisoner of war.
The POW Network is trying to honor real war heroes and expose fraudulent
claims. Schantag is a founder of the Missouri-based organization.
In 2007, Congress approved and former President George W. Bush signed
the Stolen Valor legislation. That law makes it a federal crime to
fraudulently claim to have received the nation's top military
decorations.
Schantag said Wednesday that several veterans have come forward claiming
that Crumley not only has claimed to be a prisoner of war but also has
been introduced as one at military events the past few years.
"He was never a POW and he has no right to make the claims,
especially right there in Colorado when there are former POWs right
there in the area," Schantag said.
Sterner said he received a report on Crumley around Memorial Day this
year.
Schantag said that according to her reports, Crumley told people he was
a prisoner of war during a weeklong County Veterans Service Officer
conference in Denver in May.
"That's where our original reports came from. These guys turned him
in from hearing him at meetings," Schantag said.
The veterans, Schantag said, said Crumley allegedly claimed to have been
captured in I Corps and held as a prisoner of war in South Vietnam for
three years before escaping.
According to Sterner's records, Crumley, a retired Marine, was
introduced last year as a former prisoner of war to the Colorado Board
of Veterans Affairs and a roomful of veterans.
The records state that during another event, officials invited all who
were former prisoners of war to stand and Crumley did so.
Schantag said a veteran reported to her that during the conference in
May, he sat with Crumley for lunch every day with several other Veterans
Service officers. The veteran said that Crumley claimed that, before his
capture, he was promoted to warrant officer and flew 500 combat missions
in F-4 Phantom jets. The veteran also said that Crumley claimed to be a
retired, 30-year veteran.
Schantag said the POW Network obtained Crumley's official military
records through the Freedom of Information Act and found he served 10
years in the Marines as an aircraft safety equipment mechanic, never was
promoted to warrant officer, never flew 500 combat missions and was
never a Vietnam POW.
Crumley was recently removed from his position at the state VFW and is
precluded from holding a state or local VFW elected position for five
years.
Bill Esch, Colorado State VFW commander, said that Crumley's removal had
nothing to do with the POW allegations.
Esch said that he was removed for using a VFW credit card to purchase a
laptop computer in 2007.
"The bylaws of the Crowley County post say that a person cannot buy
anything with a credit card over $500. With tax the computer was above
$500. He technically violated the bylaws," Esch said.
Esch said that Crumley is still a member of the VFW and is doing a good
job in Crowley County.
In an e-mail to The Pueblo Chieftain, Crowley County Commissioner
Matt Heimerich said, "The Board of Commissioners does not plan on
taking any further action on this issue unless formal charges against
Mr. Crumley have been proven."
Sterner said he has contacted an FBI special agent and reported Crumley
to him as a violator of the Stolen Valor Act. Sterner said the agent
will investigate this matter for possible federal violations.
Schantag said that scores of Americans, from clergymen to lawyers to
CEOs, are claiming service medals they never earned.
"We get more than 20 reports a week on this. It's an epidemic and a
major problem that is changing the history of the Vietnam War because
the majority of claims are in the Vietnam era," Schantag said.
"The more these phonies keep talking, the more they get the front
pages and the more they infiltrate the VFW, the more disgusting it
gets."
Schantag said that in the more than 40 years of its existence, the
Department of Defense's POW list has never been proven wrong.
"We've never had someone that we have accused of being either a
fraud or a phoney be able to come up with information given to the
Department of Defense to be added to the list (of POWs)," she said.
anthonym@chieftain.com
|
4:55 PM Wed, Jul 22, 2009
Tanya Eiserer/Reporter
Recently, I have received a number of emails from readers wanting to
know what's been going on with accused police imposter Ryan Caskey.
He's the 22-year-old that authorities say
duped Dallas police by pretending he was a military officer as he
helped them answer calls and make arrests.
Caskey fled the state after an encounter on the night
of April 23, when a police supervisor questioned him on a police call
in Far North Dallas and began to suspect that he was not a real
officer.
During that call, Caskey reportedly drew his gun as he kicked in an
apartment door with a rookie officer. Authorities later found his car
dumped at Love Field airport.
In early May, US. Marshals captured
him at his parent's house in Castaic, California.
A few days ago, I received an email from a man who lives near the
home of Caskey's parents. He wrote that Caskey had been spotted back
at his mother's home. He wanted to know if Caskey was out on bond or
still wanted.
After some checking, I have determined that he was released on bond
from the Los Angeles County jail several days after his arrest.
He currently faces one misdemeanor count of unlawful carrying of a
weapon and a felony indictment accusing him of impersonating a public
servant in Denton County.
Caskey, who does not appear to have a prior criminal history, wore
a bulletproof vest and carried a U.S. Marine military police badge and
a Glock handgun. He claimed to be a military police officer attached
to an FBI task force. He followed officers in his black Crown Victoria
with red and blue flashing lights in the dashboard.
Authorities said he fancied himself as a police aficionado who
often said he worked undercover for the government. In one encounter
with Arlington police, he claimed to be on an anti-terrorism task
force.
Those that knew Caskey also said he had made claims that he'd
served in the Iraq war and that he'd been a sniper. Neither of those
claims were true, military officials said.
Dallas police officials have said Caskey served in the military with
one of their officers.
I have also received a number of emails from people who say they
were duped by Caskey into believing he was something he wasn't.
The one that struck me the most came from Guy Glimpse of
California, who expressed his deep disappointment with Caskey. He had
gotten to know Caskey through Caskey's My Space page while his twins
sons were deployed.
One of his sons was killed in action in Iraq in April 2006. The
other is now a police officer.
"He (Caskey) became pretty much one of the family upon his
return from Iraq. Or so we thought," the man wrote in the email.
"We last saw him in June 2008 after his 'supposed' return from
another deployment to Iraq.
"There were several inconsistencies that occurred during that
deployment that made us question his whereabouts and motives. Suddenly
he shows back up, asks if he can go on a ride along with my police
officer son, then disappears again. Now we have confirmation that he
was in Dallas. When he showed up with a Dallas license the day after
returning from Iraq, we were highly suspicious."
"As you can tell, the majority of his story is bunk and we all
know we were played. But mostly me. This has truly broken my heart as
I was probably one of the few people who accepted him. Had I only
known."
|
MARINE CORPS TIMES
July 27, 2009
Stolen valor : Fraudulent DD-214s may be common
By William H. McMichael
bmcmichael@militarytimes.com
Simply claiming to be a Medal of Honor recipient is one
thing. Claiming that status on a falsified government form is
another.
There’s no way to know how often fakers use falsified
forms to illicitly procure government benefits, preference for
admission to schools or, as in a recent case in Florida, an
undeserved state license plate emblazoned with “Medal of
Honor.” That individual has been indicted for violating a
federal law, the Stolen Valor Act of 2005.
But news reports and private-sector military-honors
watchdogs indicate the practice is still widespread � and
that the means is often an altered or counterfeit DD-214, the form
distributed upon discharge from military service that contains a
concise capsule of a service member ’s career.
Many private watchdogs spend long hours hunting down those
who, for self-aggrandizement, claim military service and high
decorations � to gain an edge in a political campaign, for
instance.
But fakers use false DD-214s, easily modified or created
using a computer, to get benefits from the Veterans Affairs
Department. In a 2007 case, investigators caught eight people who
were receiving VA compensation for combat injuries �
although none had served in combat and two had never served in the
military. Their acts collectively cost VA $1.4 million.
“That’s eight individuals in the Seattle area, in one
bust,” said Doug Sterner, a longtime private watchdog who now
maintains the Military Times Hall of Valor database. “Now,
extrapolate that across the nation, and imagine the millions of
dollars that this runs into.” VA’s disability-claims division
does not track the number of fraudulent claims it receives, but
turns all cases over to its own inspector general, according to
Phil Budahn, a VA spokesman.
Such claims have gained publicity in recent years. That’s
largely because of the efforts of people such as Sterner and B.G.
Burkett, author of “Stolen Valor: How the Vietnam Generation Was
Robbed of Its Heroes and Its History.” The Internet has brought
about greater access to public records.
Still, James O’Neill, VA’s assistant inspector general
for investigations, said he hasn’t seen much of an increase in
his office’s fraud traffic since he began his work in 2004.
“It’s been fairly steady,” he said, adding that the use of
fraudulent DD-214s is “common” in such efforts and typically
involves an altered or counterfeit document.
Sen. Jim Webb, D-Va., a decorated Vietnam War veteran,
wants a better system and has asked VA to look into the issue of
misrepresentation of service.
“Forging or altering DD-214s to receive VA and other
benefits has been cited repeatedly in media reports, in-depth
studies and official investigations,” he said. “Since these
allegations go to the very core of military service, I have asked
the Secretary of Veterans Affairs to examine them and let me know
the results.” The problem could be easily solved, Sterner
maintains, with a public database that any agency could access
and, with a couple of keystrokes, check the legitimacy of a
person’s claim.
In a 2004 National Personnel Records Center feasibility
study, the agency concluded that every DD-214 issued since 1947
could be digitized at a cost of $12 million, resulting in $4
million of savings annually, Sterner said. The only missing piece
would be the 18 million military records that were damaged or
destroyed in a 1973 fire at the records center in St. Louis.
But Sterner said that by digitizing the general orders
filed in College Park, Md., much of the information lost in the
fire could be recovered. “The two [sets of records] could work
hand in glove and be very effective in establishing a database
that would serve multiple purposes,” he said.
|
|
NEWSMAX Magazine
August Issue / America
Phony Vets Spin Good Tales, But Dishonor Real
Heroes
by Clayton Reid
3 page article
|
|
This was one of the editorials in the Columbus
Dispatch
Editorial: Short takes
Tuesday, July 21, 2009 3:00 AM
• MILITARY
HEROES and their loved ones are right to resent people who
cheapen their sacrifices by telling false stories of valor.
Most don't have the time to track down every
fishy-sounding story and investigate its veracity, so groups such as
Mary Schantag's perform a useful service. The Missouri woman belongs
to a network of volunteers who use Google alerts and other means to
monitor news sources for claims of military heroism. They check the
stories against Department of Defense records and, when they find
someone making phony claims about military service, they expose it on
blogs across the country.
The Stolen Valor Act, a federal law passed in
2006, makes it a crime to falsely claim military honors or lie about
combat service. It's not aimed so much at barstool braggarts as at
those who attempt to gain something of value, such as a tax break or
free meals or special license plates. Its sponsor, U.S. Rep. John T.
Salazar, D-Colo., has another good idea: a bill to create a public
database of all military honors. If such a list can be made accurate
and easy to use and become well-known, it could deter false claims.
That would protect all veterans who served
and sacrificed with honor.
|
MARINE CORPS TIMES
July 27, 2009
Association wrestles with how to treat fakers
By Dan Lamothe
dlamothe@militarytimes.com
The Marine Corps Association is ignoring fraudulent
veterans in its ranks, say a growing number of critics disgusted
with the organization for publishing a member ship directory listing
dozens of unearned military decorations.
The criticism follows the association’s response to
learning that at least 40 profiles printed in the 2009 Marine Corps
Association Membership Directory had false or fraudulent medals
listed, including 16 Medals of Honor and 16 Navy Crosses. The Nation
al Personnel Records Center, which maintains former service
members’ paperwork, also had no record of at least five people
listed in the directory ever serving a day in the military.
Tom Esslinger, MCA’s chief operating officer, said no
members have been expelled from the organization, including Donald
Laisure Sr., 80, a former private who admitted to Marine Corps Times
that he pretended to be a retired four-star general with a Navy
Cross and Silver Star.
MCA, a nonprofit with about 80,000 members, is considering
what to do with Laisure. Any decision the association makes must be
approved by its board of directors, which isn’t scheduled to meet
until December, Esslinger said.
MCA posted a one-page addendum to the directory on its Web
site after the problems were outlined in the July 6 issue of Marine
Corps Times. The addendum includes corrected information for all 40
profiles originally called into question by retired Lt. Col. Thomas
Richards, a Navy Cross recipient and MCA member.
Richards first discovered irregularities in the directory
while looking for individuals eligible to join the Legion of Valor,
an organization for Medal of Honor and service cross recipients.
MCA officials said many of the incorrect profiles were not
the result of individuals lying about their military records, but
because of errors by Harris Connect, a publisher contracted to
collect information for the directory. Harris officials acknowledged
the company’s mistakes, but critics say MCA needs to launch a full
investigation of its membership, starting with those who claim
high-level military decorations and service as a general officer,
which are relatively easy to verify.
“You have to police your own,” said retired Col. Len
Hayes, executive director of the 1st Marine Division Association, a
separate non profit with about 11,000 members. “Once a guy emerges
as a phony, it’s just inconceivable that they don’t purge him
from their association.” Hayes said that after he read about the
mistakes Harris made, the 1st MarDiv Association launched an
investigation of its own membership directory, published by Harris
last year. The group is in the process of verifying members who
claim to be retired generals or recipients of the Medal of Honor and
Navy Cross, but has not found any discrepancies.
Last year, the 1st MarDiv Association demanded that two members
resign or defend their military record after their claims raised the
eyebrows of the association’s leaders, Hayes said. One of them, a
former corporal, first said he was a retired captain, but shifted
his story to say he was a retired lieutenant colonel. The second
one, a former private first class who served in Korea, said he was a
retired colonel who earned a Navy Cross as an F-4 pilot in Vietnam.
“We sent them a letter telling them to appear before our directors
to show cause on why they shouldn’t be thrown out, or to
resign,” Hayes said. “Both elected to resign, and we notified a
FBI agent in L.A. about them. That’s what the Marine Corps
Association should do.” Richards, an MCA member for 30 years, said
he still believes MCA does a lot of good work, but thinks its
leaders are trying to weather the bad publicity without making
serious, time-consuming changes.
“They haven’t demonstrated that they take it as
seriously as their statements suggest they are,” he said. “I’m
a longstanding member of the Marine Corps Association, but I think
they’ve gone astray on this one, relative to their mission, vision
and values.” Ë
|
Veterans
network roots out fake heroes
Sunday, July 19, 2009 4:03
AM
This past Memorial Day, a
Vietnam veteran in London, Ohio, shared a harrowing story.
He told a newspaper reporter
how, when he was an Army private in 1967, a North Vietnamese soldier
climbed a tree, stuck a P-10 pistol into his ear and took him
prisoner. How he survived for three months on dirty water and an ounce
of rice a day.
He said he escaped by breaking a
guard's neck and shooting the others with the AK-47 he ripped from
that dead soldier's hands.
He claimed he ran barefoot
through the jungle for 10 days to reach a Marine stronghold. He said
he earned a Silver Star for his troubles.
Within hours of the story being
published in The Madison Press, a woman in rural
Missouri heard her computer make a familiar noise.
Ding.
A Google Internet alert let Mary
Schantag know that someone, somewhere, was claiming to be a Vietnam
War prisoner. She scanned the London story, checked the Department of
Defense online list of war prisoners -- the man wasn't on it -- and
then she got busy.
By day's end, 63-year-old
Kenneth Eugene Reed was branded a liar on Schantag's Web site, http://www.pownetwork.org.
Then a large, well-connected
network of people scattered across the country spread the word on
blogs that the story couldn't possibly be true.
Schantag's group started
archiving POWs' stories 20 years ago. Now, it and others like it work
just as hard to expose fakes, and they all wanted Reed outed.
"We're not talking about an
embellished story in the back room of a Friday night fish fry at a
VFW," said Schantag, the 56-year-old wife of a former Marine.
"We're talking about men
claiming medals that they don't have, men who say they endured torture
and prison camps when they didn't. "Putting a fake hero on stage
with a real one is an insult. These men left their blood and their
body parts on the battlefields and these fakes steal their stories,
but they don't steal their nightmares or their pain."
Reed apparently did spend 17
years in the U.S. Army and served in Vietnam. He is a decorated
veteran with a Purple Heart. Madison County Veterans Service Officer
Rodger Baker confirmed that.
He said privacy rules kept him
from providing Reed's records, but he said Reed doesn't have all the
medals he claimed and that he was not a prisoner of war.
Last month, Reed admitted to The
Madison Press that his story was untrue, and he apologized to the
paper, the community and other veterans.
In an interview with The
Dispatch last week, Reed didn't want to say much and wasn't as
clear. In a circuitous conversation, he often didn't finish his
thought or sentence.
When asked whether he was a
prisoner of war, he said no. Then, he said this: "I am not a
liar. I told the truth."
When asked whether he had been
awarded, as he had claimed, a Silver Star, the military's third
highest honor, he said, "I had one, but there's no record of
it."
Reed said he made a living
mostly as a truck driver and worked in a factory. He's retired now, he
said, and doesn't have much contact with any relatives. He lives in
the city of London but said all he's ever really wanted to do is own
land and be a hog farmer.
He is, by all accounts, loyal to
the local American Legion post and helps the veterans organizations
with community events. His friends say
this national dust-up caused barely a stir in town. No one seemed to
care about what he had said.
Reed ended the conversation by
saying he wished he had done things differently in the first
interview.
Why an already-decorated veteran
would make up such a story just for the sake of it seems a bit of a
mystery, said William Schmidt, the commander of Ohio Chapter #1 of the
American ex-Prisoners of War.
Some do it to get things, such
as tax-free benefits and free meals and license plates, but most know
other veterans would quickly recognize the story as false.
"It's like a flute player
who is out of tune," Schmidt said. "Eventually, the
bandmaster will recognize that."
Michael Chakeres, a retired
optometrist from London and a former state commander of the American
Legion, knows Reed well. He has helped his friend cope with the
fallout.
"He didn't mean any harm. I
think he was only trying to get some pats on the back. He wanted
someone to say, 'Good job,' " Chakeres said.
After Reed's story was
published, the national networks called for him to be criminally
charged. The Stolen Valor Act became law in 2006 and made it a federal
offense to falsely claim military honors or lie about combat service.
There have been an estimated 40
prosecutions under the act, according to published reports last year.
The FBI investigates violations, but could not update those numbers or
say whether any of those prosecutions were from Ohio.
A spokesman for U.S. Rep. John
T. Salazar, the Colorado Democrat responsible for the law, said Reed
and others like him are not the intended targets.
"In theory, the Stolen
Valor Act is for those who get something out of their lie, someone who
gets some benefit," spokesman Eric Wortman said.
Salazar has introduced another
bill that would create a public database of all military honors. It is
under consideration by the Armed Services Committee.
Though such a national honor
roll would have many benefits and uses, a clear one would be that a
veteran's claims of medals could be quickly vetted.
Chakeres, a former Navy Seabee,
said veterans are proud of their service and protective of their
sacrifices. He understands the voracity with which these groups go
after someone who lied.
But he said a little empathy for
a misguided veteran can go a long way, too.
hzachariah@dispatch.com
|
Fort Myers mayoral hopeful's claim may violate law
Record shows no Special Forces stint
By Gabriella Souza • gsouza@news-press.com •
July 17, 2009
The man who authored the Stolen Valor Act said he believes it is
possible Fort Myers mayoral candidate Derrell Gardner could be
prosecuted under his law's guidelines.
On his Web site, Gardner claims he was in Special Forces. His
military record gives no indication he completed Special Forces
training, and former Special Forces soldiers say this shows he never
served in the elite unit.
The Stolen Valor Act is a federal law enacted in 2006 that makes
it illegal to falsely claim any military decorations and medals.
Military historian Doug Sterner said because Gardner would have
received a decoration for completing Army Special Forces training he
is in violation of the act.......
http://www.news-press.com/article/20090717/NEWS0110/907170388/1085/NEWS01
|
|
http://webb.senate.gov/newsroom/record.cfm?id=315730&
July 14, 2009
Webb Calls on Veterans Affairs Department to Examine Reports of
Misrepresentation of Military Service
Letter Asks for Immediate Action to Root out Fraud and Abuse in VA
System
|
http://www.spokesman.com:80/stories/2009/jul/14/phony-covert-military-agent-gets-six-months-swindl/
A man who convinced his girlfriend he was a covert military agent
and swindled thousands of dollars to fund his gambling habit will
spend the next six months in jail.
The woman felt so bad her bank lost money that she repaid it.
Now her ex-boyfriend, Thai M. Cao, is required to pay her back
after he’s released from jail.
Cao, 24, also faces a theft charge in Colorado, where he worked in
a military finance department before becoming addicted to gambling and
ruining his career, he told Spokane County Superior Court Judge
Maryann Moreno on Tuesday.
Cao was convicted of stealing thousands of dollars from four
people, including the woman, in a complicated check kiting scheme that
basically involved him finding people to cash checks for him that
later bounced.
“All my thinking was ‘Maybe I could win this
time,’” Cao said. “I never meant to steal from them. My
intent was just to borrow.”
Cao pleaded guilty Tuesday to four counts of first-degree theft,
four counts of forgery, one count of third-degree theft and one count
of unlawful possession of a payment instrument.
In a sentencing deal worked out by public defender Kevin Griffin
and Deputy Prosecutor David Stevens and approved by Moreno, Cao
qualified for the first-time offender program and will serve six
months in jail and 24 months on probation, pay restitution and attend
counseling for gambling addiction.
His charges could have earned him 43 months in prison.
“I see a lot of people, some of which I like more than others,”
Griffin said. “I think Mr. Cao is a very decent young man with a
very serious gambling problem.”
The four victims described Cao as extremely intelligent and said
they have forgiven him, Stevens said.
Along with Cao’s ex-girlfriend, whom he met in an Internet chat
room and said he had planned to marry, other victims repaid their
banks for the missing funds, Griffin said.
“These folks must have a very large heart, because I’m not so
sure that I could be so forgiving,” Moreno said.
Cao has been in the Spokane County Jail for two months after
spending time in military custody in Oklahoma and in a Colorado jail
in August, Griffin said.
Cao used his military experience when conning people into the
scheme, which began when he told his girlfriend he needed money
because someone was stealing money at work in Colorado and he was
being blamed for it, according to a statement of facts filed in
October 2008.
“A short time later he came back to Spokane, originally saying he
was on vacation and then admitted he was AWOL from the military but
that was only a cover up for his real purpose as a CID (Army Criminal
Investigation Command) agent on secret mission in Spokane,” the
statement reads.
|
Stolen Valor Act
Watchdog
blog: Special Forces vet questions whether Fort Myers ...
The News-Press - Fort Myers,FL,USA
The Stolen Valor Act is a federal law enacted in 2006 that
makes it illegal to falsely claim any military decorations and medals.
It's unclear whether the ...
Watchdog blog: Special Forces vet questions whether Fort Myers
mayoral candidate violated federal law
|
07/14/2009
S&S has a new blog, and thought
you might want to pass this url along to you list. It has the recent
cases:
http://blogs.stripes.com/blogs/stripes-central/rash-phony-vets-fake-medal-recipients-exposed
Sincerely,
Doug
“Congress is
complicit in the Stolen Valor cases we see in the news every week by its
lack of even taking the time to learn how big the problem is or how
simple the solution can be. Representative Susan Davis (San Diego, CA)
seems to be our biggest obstacle; as Chairwoman of the Sub-Committee to
which the "Military Valor Roll of Honor Act" is assigned, she
refuses even to give one hour to a hearing on this issue, despite the
fact that one-third of the members of her sub-committee are co-sponsors
of the bill to fix this. One would think preserving the history of our
TRUE heroes, while quickly exposing the myriad of phonies out there,
deserves at least a hearing.”
Doug Sterner
C. Douglas Sterner
3111 Thatcher Ave.
Pueblo, CO 81005
(719) 564-1755
|
Subject: FW: What a Week !!!!
Date:
Fri, 10 Jul 2009 23:37:18 -0600
Big story is the poor victim of the
Vietnam War in Houston…suffering PTSD and Survivors Guilt after
becoming “disillusioned by the prejudice he says was within his
unit,” who can blame him for awarding himself medals, giving
interviews with unbelievable stories, and posing with a REAL MOH
Recipient….
http://www.chron.com/disp/story.mpl/metropolitan/6524197.html
Please take the time to register and leave a note of sympathy for Mr.
Bass…..
AND…this just out today regarding one of the NINE Phony Navy Cross
recipients we encountered in the last week of May (Memorial Day
Weekend)…again, in Texas…. http://www.rockwallheraldbanner.com/local/local_story_191195018.html
“LaFlamme said he had undergone a name change in a “long,
drawn-out story that I’m not allowed to talk about.” Those
covert ops and “sealed records” get you in trouble every time…..
And, of course…in case you missed it our guy who lied about serving in
Vietnam and then forged the paperwork to show he had completed the
community service he was sentenced to for that Stolen Valor: http://www.orovillemr.com/news/ci_12808049
Oh yes… and the CIVILIAN (never served) who earned the Navy Cross and
Silver Star… FOX NEWS in Arizona did a GREAT PIECE on this in case you
didn’t see it: http://www.myfoxphoenix.com/dpp/news/only_on_fox/fake_marine_07_06_2009
And FINALLY…Tom Richards (NX/RVN) good work in:
1) Busting a phony Navy Cross Recipient two days before he was to be
Grand Marshall of an Independence Day Parade: http://www.rgj.com/article/20090708/FERNLEY01/907080313/1306/FERNLEY/Legion-of-Valor-weighing-whether-to-pursue-charges-in-Navy-Cross-controversy
2) The Problem of Erroneous Claims in the MCA Directory: http://www.marinecorpstimes.com/news/2009/07/marine_mca_fakers_070609w/
Sincerely,
Doug
C. Douglas Sterner
3111 Thatcher Ave.
Pueblo, CO 81005
(719) 564-1755
|
By Dan
Lamothe - Staff writer
Posted : Monday Jul 6, 2009 7:01:15 EDT
Donald Laisure Sr. has a biography that could wow nearly anyone.
The retired four-star general earned the Navy Cross, the Silver
Star and an Air Medal in a 54-year career that included service in
Vietnam, Panama and the Persian Gulf War, according to his profile in
the 2009 Marine Corps Association Directory. He went on to become the
CEO and chairman of the board at Laisure Oil Refinery & Production
Company in Greenville, Texas, the directory says.
It’s a great story of a self-made man making it big.
Too bad it’s not true.
Laisure’s history is one of some 40 false or erroneous profiles
in the directory, which was published early this year. Completed in
November, it is available to members for $80.
Members of the Legion of Valor, the P.O.W. Network and other
organizations identified the incorrect entries after a member thought
the number of MCA listings claiming Navy Crosses seemed too high. They
believe there could be many more.
A Marine Corps Times review of the initial 40 profiles in question
and official service records confirms the MCA directory contains
incorrect medals, including 16 fraudulent Medals of Honor, 16 fake
Navy Crosses and eight bogus Silver Stars. Additionally, the National
Personnel Records Center, which maintains former service members’
paperwork, has no record of at least five people listed in the
directory ever serving in the military.
Questioned about his past, Laisure, 80, initially insisted it was
all legitimate. But when pressed, he said he was never an officer and
served less than a year on active duty before leaving the service as a
private. California records also show he was once married to convicted
murderer Susan Atkins, the ex-wife of serial killer Charles Manson,
and Greenville officials say they have no record of his company ever
existing.
“I guess I just wanted to be something I wasn’t,” he said.
“I’ve just always admired the Marine Corps, and I hope I’ve done
no harm.”
Mary Schantag, co-founder of the P.O.W. Network, expressed outrage
that MCA published the directory, available to members through a
third-party organization, without proper background checks.
“It negates the true honor of the Marine Corps when you’re
filling up your membership with phonies,” she said.
Association officials say that’s blowing things out of
proportion. Tom Esslinger, MCA’s chief operating officer, said some
entries are wrong simply because of data entry mistakes.
The discrepancies in the 2009 directory — a listing of the
association’s estimated 80,000 members — were first discovered by
retired Lt. Col. Thomas Richards, a Navy Cross recipient and member of
the Legion of Valor, an organization for recipients of the Medal of
Honor, the Navy Cross, the Distinguished Service Cross and the Air
Force Cross.
Richards said he searched the directory for individuals eligible to
join the Legion of Valor, but was struck by an unlikely number of Navy
Cross recipients.
“It just occurred to me: What if there are people in here who are
claiming fraudulent Medals of Honor and service crosses?” he said.
Among the most amazing stories is Laisure’s. He married Atkins,
now 61, on Sept. 2, 1981, in Frontera, Calif., according to their
wedding license. A UPI news account of Atkins’ 1981 parole board
hearing describes him as “Donald (Fla$h) Laisure, 52, the
self-styled Texas millionaire who married Atkins” in a jailhouse
ceremony.
It’s unclear if Laisure was a millionaire, then or now, or if
that was a fabrication, too. He and Atkins divorced a few months after
the ceremony, with Atkins later saying that Laisure was “not being
totally honest with me,” according to a transcript of her 1985
parole board hearing.
Esslinger said the organization began working on the problems after
the Legion of Valor raised concerns in March. The association plans to
release an “update” to the directory this summer, listing
corrected information for the 40 individuals flagged, and has sent
letters to each of them notifying that will happen. MCA officials
contracted with an outside organization, Harris Connect, to collect
the information for the directory and do “everything it can” to
ensure the legitimacy of its membership, Esslinger said. Harris also
completed MCA directories in 2005, 2001 and 1998.
Harris received more than 31,000 updates from MCA members in the
process of developing the directory, said Nancy Liguori, a company
official. Harris launched an audit, listening to recorded telephone
conversations with the members in question, and eventually concluded
the errors were caused by employees making inaccurate selections on a
computer screen.
It is still possible, however, that a “small number of the 40”
lied about their service record, Esslinger said. MCA staff members, he
said, were aware of the dubious nature of Laisure’s claims and
questioned him a few years ago, but he was allowed to remain a member.
“We don’t want to embarrass these people because most of them
are totally innocent,” Esslinger said. “We got Harris to
acknowledge their role in this and to send a letter to the Legion of
Valor, and as far as we’re concerned, that’s the end of it.”
That’s not good enough, said retired Col. William Bridgeham,
whose profile was botched. He quit the association after getting a
letter questioning his record, which military documents show includes
a Distinguished Flying Cross that was included in the directory as a
Distinguished Service Cross.
“It was expressed to me in such an insulting way that I went back
to them and told them to pound sand,” he said. “The association
had absolutely terrible quality assurance on that publication.”
|
MARINE
CORPS TIMES
6 July 2009
|
[EDITORIALS
]
A
black eye for MCA
The Marine Corps Association ought to be a pretty exclusive
club. Turns out, it has a problem with fakers.
Not one or two or three, but possibly dozens. At least 40
member profiles published in the organization's most recent
directory are flawed. There are 16 bogus Medals of Honor, for
example, 16 fake Navy Crosses and at least eight phony Silver
Stars listed, based on a Marine Corps Times analysis. There
are also at least five members listed who claim to have been
Marines, but who appear never to have even served in the
Corps.
There are victims in this mess, as well. A handful of
legitimate combat heroes are listed with incorrect medals
because of data-entry errors made by the third-party firm
hired by the MCA to update its 2009 members directory.
Unfortunately, some of them were lumped in with the phonies
after the directory's quality problems were exposed by an
astute member of the MCA and Legion of Valor, an organization
for recipients of the military's highest combat decorations. A
Navy Cross recipient, retired Marine Lt. Col.
Thomas Richards was looking for fellow Marines to recruit for
the Legion of Valor when the number of highly decorated vets
he was finding triggered his faker radar.
A nonprofit organization comprising some 80,000 current and
former Marines and dependents, the MCA fills a vital role in
the Marine Corps community. It relies on membership fees and
donations from members to host professional military education
series and annual awards ceremonies, among other key
initiatives.
To some, 40 bad apples in an association that large might not
seem like a crisis. It is. It under mines the group's
integrity and flouts one of the Corps' most basic, sacred
principles: honor.
Moreover, it's against the law to claim false military honors,
and the MCA has inadvertently endorsed some of those false
claims.
The MCA's chief operating officer, Tom Esslinger, admits the
possibility that "a small number of the 40"
lied about their service records, but says others are innocent
and the MCA has no intention to "embarrass these
people." Why
not? The MCA was used by at least five fakers to advance their
lies and to legitimize their claims. Having been embarrassed
by them, it ought to be putting in place new rules and systems
to ensure this doesn't happen again, and to expose fraudulent
claims for what they are.
To do otherwise is to quietly advance their underhanded
agendas and, in the process, dilute what it means to be one of
the few and the proud who can legitimately call themselves
Marines.
The most egregious fakery case within the MCA exposed thus far
involves a man who claimed for years that he was a highly deco
rated four-star general. Pressed by Marine Corps Times, he
"fessed up" to being a phony.
Esslinger said the association's staff learned a few years
back that this individual, now 80, had a dubious service
record. They questioned him, too, but he held fast to his
claims and remained a member. Rather than do the right thing
and report him to authorities, the MCA chose to look the other
way.
As this and other recent faker cases confirm, the problem is
not exclusive to the MCA or any one age group. Further, they
prove this sad, shameful trend isn't going away anytime soon.
Marine Corps Times has reported on three cases of stolen valor
in the past month alone. (Check out the May 25 and June 22
issues for a reminder).
For the good of its reputation " and its ability to
attract new members and funding" the Marine Corps
Association must clean house now.. Expel the known liars, comb
the books for others and modify the screening process for new
members so no other impostors have the slightest chance of
sneaking in.
|
|