|
BERNARD RAMSEY Actual Military Records |
||||||||||||||||||||
|
quote
E4 RAMSEY BERNARD JR got out of the Air Force on 20 April 1972. He did not serve in Vietnam. His MOS was 30630 which was Apprentice Electronic Communications and Cryptographic Equipment Systems Repairman. end quote |
||||||||||||||||||||
|
Sent: Thursday, July 27, 2006 7:22 AM
”A Window of Hope for U.S. POWs in Laos, Cambodia, and Vietnam”
– Bernie |
||||||||||||||||||||
|
||||||||||||||||||||
|
Date: Thu, 27 Jul 2006 16:42:18 -0700 (PDT) From: Sherman Stephen Subject: Re: Fwd: Re: Question
Doesn't come up in my database. Doesn't sound quite kosher to me.
|
||||||||||||||||||||
|
...... Another common feature of false
POW stories is a claim to have been freed in a dramatic rescue by US Navy
Seals, Special Forces, or other elite unit. US forces made many, many
heroic rescues of downed airmen and other Americans in desperate
situations. They also carried out many operations aimed at rescuing
American POWs from prison camps; however, the only
rescue operation that freed an American POW from captivity was a July 1969
operation by Republic of Vietnam Armed Forces (RVNAF) troops from a
Regional Forces unit, a Provincial Reconnaissance Unit, and the
Reconnaissance Company of the Army of the Republic of Vietnam (ARVN) 5th
Regiment. Unfortunately, the freed American died a short time later
from injuries a guard inflicted on him before rescuers could reach him. US
forces carried out several operations that led to the rescue of the
crews and passengers of downed American aircraft who were evading capture.
The movie "BAT 21" is based on one such incident. US forces also
took part in several operations that led to the rescue of RVNAF prisoners
from POW camps. For example, Operation Cranberry Bog in August 1968 led to
the rescue of 45 ARVN POWs. In another example, a US Navy SEAL,
Richard G. Couch, led a successful rescue of 19 ARVN prisoners.
Also, there were instances in which American forces accidentally happened
upon Americans who were trying to escape from captivity and rescued them.
The most famous of these incidents was the rescue of US Army 1st
Lieutenant James N. Rowe on 31 December 1968 (see book entitled "Five
Years to Freedom," by James N. Rowe, Ballantine Books, paperback
edition 1984, available on line from Barnes and Noble). In another
incident, a helicopter crew rescued Army Sgt. Wm. Taylor on May 6, 1968.
A force of armed helicopters attacked a guerrilla camp with machine guns
and rockets, unaware that Sgt Taylor was in the camp. Sgt Taylor, who was
still recovering from a compound fracture to one leg, a shattered knee,
and numerous abrasions and burns he suffered in an air crash on 20 March
1968, received additional wounds from one of the rockets; yet he still
managed to take advantage of the confusion during the air attack to crawl
out of the camp and into a clearing where he signaled the crew of one of
the helicopters. While there were many heroic rescues of downed
airmen and other Americans from difficult situations, there were no other
dramatic rescues of Americans from POW camps.
Captain John "Mike" McGrath, USN
(Ret) at: e-mail mmcgrath@iex.net
|
||||||||||||||||||||
|
.... "As you will note, while this person served honorably in the
Air Force, there are none of the assignments which have ascribed to him
and none of the high-profile medals that he claimed to have received.
"While there may have been a short tour of duty in Vietnam, there
is no record of him being assigned to a prisoner-release-team as he
claimed and no record of him being assigned to the Army Special Forces
in a similar capacity. It is also extremely unlikely that a person
with this person's training would have conducted such high-risk
assignments.
"This person's assignments range from 1964 when he was an airman recruit, and assigned as a cook; to 1965 when he was a cook while awaiting training as an air-traffic-controller in 1967; to 1969 when he was assigned in Ohio as an air-traffic-controller; to 1970-71 when he was assigned as a Crypto Maintenance Technician in Texas; to 1972 when he retired from the Air Force.
"With this record in mind, it would have been difficult for him to
have found the time to have "extracted approximately 179 U.S.
servicemen from behind enemy lines in Vietnam, Laos and Cambodia. He
even had problems getting his retirement because it was so difficult to
track his classified military record." Apparently there was
no such difficulty, because his entire history and is recorded in
these records. Additionally, he did not have sufficient time in
the service to have been "retired." He spent a total of
eight years in the Air Force while retirement, unless there is a major
disability, requires a minimum of twenty years of service. ...
Michael |
||||||||||||||||||||
|
.Sent: Friday, November 03, 2006 8:14 AM
.. 3) Mr. Ramsey's activities during the Vietnam War were
> apparently not declassified until after his relatively recent
death. At
> his funeral at Arlington National Cemetary (a location and
institution
> which I understand you are directly associated with), official
> representatives of the Department of Defense read portions of his
> formerly classified service record -- and it was at that point that
I
> realized that this quiet unassuming individual actually LIVED the
great
> American Veteran principle of "NO TROOPS LEFT BEHIND".
In this day and
> age of foreign governments saying that there is nothing unique
about
> American veterans, this principle is one of many we at the American
> Legion wish to honor out of respect for our proud traditions.
I very
> much appreciate the material you just sent me, but having been a
> government-type for twenty years, I also recognize when something
is left
> out of a transcript or record -- please note that on the NA Form
13164
> (Rev 02-02) second page at the bottom where the transcript reads
"For
> Deceased Veteran Only", that the record says "NA"
for Date of Death,
> Location of Death, and Place of Burial. Since you and I BOTH
know that
> Bernard is dead, and that he was buried at Arlington National
Cemetary,
> it should be clear to BOTH of us that this report is the NOT
classified
> version - it doesn't even take into account that he is deceased!
The
> material read at his funeral prior to or after the gun salutes
included
> the formerly classified assignments that were not declassified
until his
> death. I was one of about 40 individuals at this funeral, and
if it
> would ease your mind any, I can list about 20 NON-relatives that
heard
> the same record I heard - should you wish to pursue this further.
> 4) At the
ceremony we held in Annapolis on the day AFTER the
> news article, an extremely high ranking government official (who IS
still
> in a classified status) revealed to the 60 or so attendees (which
> included, by the way, representatives from several congressional
and
> senatorial offices, but NO news media at the actual event) that he
> himself had been rescued by Mr. Ramsey and his team. He
stated that he
> had been shot, was for four days bleeding and ultimately
unconscious
> behind enemy lines in Cambodia, knowing he was dead to the world,
and
> then awoke sometime later in a U.S. service hospital -- not knowing
> anything about who or how he had been rescued. As this
gentleman later
> rose in the ranks of the government and received access to
classified
> records, he made it a point to find out who had saved him. He
stated
> that it was Mr. Ramsey and his team, and it developed into a
lifetime
> friendship. This gentleman stated that had it not been for
the tradition
> of "No Troops Left Behind" that Mr. Ramsey and his team
lived by, then
> this gentleman would have no children, nor would he have the many
> grandchildren he now has, nor would he have had over 40 years of
> government service. Maybe, he stated, one of his
grandchildren or great
> grandchildren will be the next great U.S. President, or the
scientist
> that cures Cancer - but none of it would have happened if Bernie
Ramsey
> had not rescued him. There was not a dry eye in the Post when this
> gentleman told his story. Knowing this gentleman's very high
status in
> classified operations, I was surprised that he shared this much
with us -
> and I am sure he would NOT have, if the news media had properly
covered
> the dedication.
......
>So now, Michael, we get to the heart of the matter. I and my
collegues
>applaud the American tradition of TRUTH - and your questioning
throughout
>our nation of claims of heroism is applaudable. But I must ask
why are
>you pursuing Mr. Ramsey's classified (but apparently not yet
officially
>published) service record -- when there is substantial evidence that
it is
>bonafide and when there is NO ONE to gain by telling an untruth.
I am
>sure there are claims that are worthy of pursuing, but this is not
one of
>them - and I doubt all the DoD high-ups are going to wish to engage
with
>you on a debate regarding Mr. Ramsey - I wouldn't ask them to!
More
>importantly, Michael, is the consumption of your time on this even
worthy
>of what you COULD be doing for our newest Veterans in showing them
the
>proud tradition of Americanism that I truly believe Bernie silently
>portrayed? I understand that (second hand -- I haven't asked
for your
>service record, and heard only by word of mouth that may not be
valid)
>that you were a POW - you are EXACTLY the type of veteran we wish to
have
>our newest veterans talking with. What you must have endured
speaks
>loudest for faith in God, Country, and the American way of life.
Can I
>interest you in coming to speak at our Legion on Americanism - why
this
>country is head and shoulders above all the rest in LIVING the
freedoms
>that other countries only pay lip-service to? If I can
convince you to
>come and visit, I will certainly try to talk that high-ranking
government
>official that Bernie Ramsey rescued to attend and speak with you in
>private. Under those circumstances, I am certain you mind will
rest with
>the knowledge that while Bernie Ramsey himself never went through
the
>indignities and demeaning treatment our POWs have endured, he was
and in
>his memory is a hero to reflect upon.
Jim Lenz |
||||||||||||||||||||
Jim Lenz
1st Vice Commander
American Legion Post 7 - Annapolis
Mr. Lenz:
First...Thanks to you and all the FAA guys and gals who safely guided
me
through the skies during my second career in civil aviation. I
retired off the
757/767 at UAL at age 60.
My first career was with the Navy for a total of 28 1/2 years in
uniform.
Never have I heard a more fanciful story of BS as the farcical yarn
told by
friends of Mr. Ramsey. Mr. Patterson brings up a lot of valid
points. The
one additional point that I would bring up that no one has mentioned
is:
Please name just one name of those hapless souls who were rescued from
behind enemy lines. No one can, because the situations described
never
occurred. By the way, I can't find a single valid point that you
bring up.
Please name the name of the "high official" who was rescued
from a
captive situation. You can't, because the event never occurred.
I suggest
you call Mr. Larry Greer, PAO for DPMO in this regard. He
is info copied
on this message. He is only a phone call away, during normal
Washington
DC working hours, at: 703-699-1169.
The BS is so deep that in one article by Jennifer Carr, For the
Captial, 29
July 2006 writes, "Mr. Ramsey and his team extracted
approximately 179
U.S. servicemen from behind enemy lines in Vietnam, Laos and
Cambodia." She can only get this type of hogwash from you
guys, his
friends who provided her the information. She didn't make it up,
someone
gave it to her. Neither you nor any of his friends can give me a
single
name of the 179. I can give you the name, rank, address, etc. of
every one
of the real 660 POWs. Why can't you give me one name of the 179?
You see, I deal with facts, not fiction. Mr. Greer at Defense
Prisoner of
War/Missing Personnel Office deals with facts. Mary at POW
Network
deals with facts. Michael Patterson deals with facts.
Facts can be verified.
BS can be thrown around with abandon and never verified.
You said in your letter, "...official representatives of the
Department of
Defense read portions of his formerly classified service record."
Please
provide the names of these official representatives of DoD. I'd
like to ask
them where they got their information as I doubt that DoD would
knowingly
endorse such a falsehood.
We, the real surviving 660 POWs of the Vietnam War can attest that
there
was never a rescued POW (rescued by Ramsey, as you mentioned) with
us. We had all the CIA and covert guys with us, and they are all
listed by
DPMO in their PMSEA list. They are current members of our
organization,
NAM-POWs Corporation, a 501 (c) (19) veterans corporation for the
former
POW of Laos, Cambodia, China, and Vietnam during the Vietnam War.
There has never been a verified captive who was rescued other than
those
listed on the PMSEA.
DPMO has the official list of all 3,797 names of MIAS (includes 30
escapees and 330 repatriated POWs) on their web site at:
I have been helping Mary at POW Network uncover over 1,400 frauds for
the past 8 years. It is a shame that Mr. Ramsey's friends, aided
by
American Legion Post 7-Annapolis, have held this guy's name up to
ridicule. This horse sheiss stuff about classified service
records being
declassified and read at funerals, classified missions that are still
classified, service in Vietnam that cannot be verified by official
records, and
on and on, is just too much to fathom. 21-gun salutes for
someone who
doesn't rate a 21 gun salute. I don't think so. The horse
sheiss just gets
deeper and deeper. Whoever started this mess and got Mr.
Ramsey's
name up on a marquee for the whole world to laugh at should be ashamed
of himself. I'm afraid that Mr. Ramsey's name will now properly
be included
on Mary's list of wannabes. The guy was probably just an
ordinary guy who
did his honorable service for 20 years and retired. For you guys
to make
him out to be something he wasn't is just not right. Let the guy
and his
family rest in peace.
My bottom line....you might have meant well, but it looks like the
"extremely
high ranking government official (who IS still in a classified
status)" and the
rest of you have pulled off a scam of the first degree. You should be
ashamed of yourself for pulling the offices of Lt. Governor Ehrlich,
Senator
Mikulski, and Senator Sarbanes (i.e., their representative staff
members
who attended) into this scam. If I can find their e-mail
addresses, I will info
copy them on this message. Good luck explaining to them why you
invited
them.
Sincerely,
John M. McGrath, Captain USN (Ret)
POW in NVN for 5 years 8 months
|
||||||||||||||||||||